Posts

Showing posts from June, 2025

Responding to Science, Evidence, and the Resurrection

 This is a response to an article, Science, Evidence, and the Resurrection, by S. Joshua Swamidass. https://peacefulscience.org/prints/excerpts/science-evidence-resurrection/ He is a scientist, but nevertheless starts by making a poke at science. Science is full of trust-like faith. We believe grand, counterintuitive things because we trust the accounts of trustworthy sources. Okay, sure, science does rely on trust. So does sitting on a chair; you are trusting that chair to take your wait. So does driving; you are trusting your fellow drives to stick to their side of the road. What it comes down to is whether that trust is warranted . I think it is in these examples. Swamidass wants us to think we can trust that the resurrection happened with a similar degree of confidence, and I really do not think that is the case. What is the evidence from which grew my trust? A brief and incomplete outline is included here. This evidence is not an answer, but it raises the question. All we need...

Chimp DNA is 99% like human DNA

This is a claim that is used a lot, but is not actually true. There is a paper in Nature that came out just a few weeks ago and goes into a comparison of the genome of the Great Apes in detail. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-08816-3 It uses some abbreviations that might not be obvious (and I hope I got right): HSA - Humans (Homo sapien) PTR - Chimpanzee (Pan troglodyte) PPA - Bonobo (Pan paniscus) GGO - Gorilla (Gorilla gorilla) PPY - Bornean orangutan (Pongo pygmaeus) PAB - Sumatran orangutan (Pongo abelii) Turns out the differences are significant - rather more than 1% - but it very much fits the evolutionary model. "Our analyses dated the human–chimpanzee split between 5.5 and 6.3 million years ago (Ma; minimum to maximum estimate of divergence), the African ape split at 10.6–10.9 Ma and the orangutan split at 18.2–19.6 Ma ... Consequently, we estimated that the human–chimpanzee–bonobo ancestral population size (average Ne = 198,000) is larger than that of the human...

Why think Christianity is wrong?

This is specifically about modern, mainstream Christianity. Some may not apply to certain fringe beliefs. In no particular order. Different beliefs Different Christians have significantly different beliefs. By significant, I mean differences worth going to war over. If Christianity was true, and its adherents were really in daily commune with God, they would all have the same understanding of their religion. Contradictions in gospels Contradictions indicate the stories are at best heavily embellished, and at worst simply made up. The women who saw the empty tomb told no one in one account, and ran to tell people in another account. The risen Jesus went on ahead to meet the disciples in Galilee in one account, and appeared to them in Jerusalem and told them to stay in the city in another. Plus, two wildly different nativity stories. No trinity The trinity is a fundamental tenet of Christianity, but is missing from the Bible except in the most obscure verses. Why did Jesus never make it ...