Explaining Away Jesus' Resurrection
This is a response to an article by Gary Habermas, "Explaining Away Jesus' Resurrection: The Recent Revival of Hallucination Theories", published in 2001. The article can be found here:
https://www.garyhabermas.com/articles/crj_explainingaway/crj_explainingaway.htm
He starts by giving a historical overview of Hallucination Theories that I am going to skip over, and jump straight to "A Critique of the Hallucination Hypothesis".
One of the central issues in this entire discussion concerns whether a group of people can witness the same hallucination. Most psychologists dispute the reality of such occurrences, as pointed out below. A rare attempt suggesting that collective hallucinations are possible, without any application to Jesus' resurrection, is made by Leonard Zusne and Warren Jones. They point to phenomena such as claimed sightings of the virgin Mary and other accompanying reports from groups of people. In cases like these, "expectation" and "emotional excitement" are "a prerequisite for collective hallucinations." In such groups we see the "emotional contagion that so often takes place in crowds moved by strong emotions . . . ."
Well the disciples had just witnessed Jesus' crucifixion, so surely strong emotions there. Did they expect to see Jesus after his death? The gospels certainly have Jesus telling them that would happen.
Alternatively, I would suggest a solitary experience by Peter (as per 1 Cor 15:5), which built the expectation, and then a later group experience, developing from that.
But favoring collective hallucinations is highly problematic, and on several grounds. (1) To begin, the chief examples of "collective hallucinations" provided by Zusne and Jones were group religious experiences such as Marion apparitions. But these citations simply beg the question regarding whether such experiences could possibly be objective, or even supernatural, at least in some sense. In other words, why must a naturalistic, subjective explanation be assumed? This seems to rule them out in an a priori manner, before the data are considered.
If I understand Habermas here, he is saying group sightings of Mary maybe actual supernatural sightings of the mother of Jesus, and hence not group hallucination. What he seems to miss is that they may not.
(2) Further, the collective hallucination thesis is unfalsifiable. It could be applied to purely natural, group sightings, simply calling them group hallucinations, too. On this thesis, crucial epistemic criteria seem to be missing. How do we determine normal occurrences from group hallucinations?
So what? Of course it would be great if the thesis was unfalsifiable, if we could determine these occurrences. But the fact that we cannot does not magically make them disappear.
(3) Even if it could be established that groups of people witnessed hallucinations, it is critical to note that it does not at all follow that these experiences were therefore collective. If, as most psychologists assert, hallucinations are private, individual events, then how could groups share exactly the same subjective visual perception? Rather, it is much more likely that the phenomena in question are either illusions--perceptual misinterpretations of actual realities [xxvii] -- or individual hallucinations.
It is interesting how Habermas says "it is much more likely that". Can he really claim that the probability of God resuurecting someone is much higher than that of a hallucination? I wonder how he evaluated that?
If I was cynical I would think he is starting from the assumption that the Bible is true...
Moreover, the largest series of problems results from comparing this thesis to the New Testament accounts of Jesus' resurrection appearances. And here, the explanatory power of this hypothesis is severely challenged, since much of the data not only differs from, but actually contradicts, the necessary conditions for "collective hallucinations." One of these issues will be mentioned here, with others following below.
And here we see his assumption in action. The explanatory power of this hypothesis is severely challenged only if we assume the Bible is true.
If we reject that assumption, it works. The disciples saw something they took to be Jesus in Galilee, and that was the impetus for the start of Christianity. But the empty tomb and all those sightings in and around Jerusalem, they were made up later.
(4) For instance, Zusne and Jones argue that "expectation" and "emotional excitement" are "prerequisites" before such group experiences will occur. In fact, expectation "plays the coordinating role." [xxviii] But this scenario contradicts the emotional state of the early witnesses of Jesus' resurrection appearances. Even psychologically, the early believers were confronted face-to-face with the utter realism of the recent and unexpected death of their best friend, whom they had hoped would rescue Israel. As those recent events unfolded in a whirlwind of Jesus' physical beatings, crucifixion, and seeming abandonment, the normal response would be fear, disillusionment, and depression. To suppose that these believers would exhibit "expectation" and "emotional excitement" in the face of these stark circumstances would require of them responses that would scarcely be exhibited at a funeral! All indications are that Jesus' disciples would exhibition the very opposite emotions from what Zusne and Jones convey as the necessary requirement.
But not if Peter had a solitary experience first that he then reported to the others. That does leave Peter's experience to explain, but that was not a group experience, so Habermas' objections do not apply.
By comparison, the disciples' experience is totally unlike those in the other cases above where pilgrims expressly traveled long distances, exuberantly gathering with the explicit desire to see something special. There would seem to be very meager grounds of comparison here with Jesus' disciples.
Is that really an objection? Sure what happened was different to what pilgrims experience, but that does not prove it cannot have happened.
Kent has suggested that Paul experienced a conversion disorder, a psychological condition characterized by physical symptoms like blindness or paralysis in the absence of specific neurological or medical causes. Such was brought about by his inner turbulance, conflict, doubt, and guilt. Goulder agrees about Paul, but adds that Peter and others, say perhaps James, were also suffering from the same problem.
But again, we must align our hypotheses with the facts, and multiple problems oppose this interpretation, as well. (1) Initially, only Paul is known to have manifested any such symptoms, so Goulder's inclusion of the others is not factually grounded.
There seems a good argument that Paul had some kind of epileptic seizure.
The interface between epilepsy and religiosity has been a long-standing matter of debate. Epilepsy has affected several religious leaders throughout history. Hyperreligiosity may be observed in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy as a component of the so-called Gastaut-Geschwind syndrome which involves other behavioral and personality traits such as hyposexuality, viscosity, philosophical concerns, sense of personal destiny, hypergraphy, emotionality, and irritability. Saint Paul, the Apostle, probably had temporal lobe epilepsy. He was a genius man of intellectual excellence and refined culture, whose life and writings exerted a decisive influence on Western history. The current paper investigates the elements of Gastaut-Geschwind syndrome in Saint Paul’s life and Epistles and discusses the potential influence of these traits on Pauline theology.
Habermas seems to be saying that that is not grounds for supposing the same of the disciples. And I agree; that feels like something different. But still hallucination.
(2) Simply a huge problem is that, from what we know about Paul and James in particular, there were no mitigating grounds to suppose such a disorder. We have no indication that there was the slightest inner conflict, doubt, or guilt concerning their previous rejection of Jesus' teachings. Critics agree that James was an unbeliever during Jesus' earthly ministry (John 7:5; cf. Mark 3:21). Paul's skepticism is even better known, since he persecuted early Christians (1 Cor. 15:9; Gal. 1:13, 23). But we do not know of any guilt on Paul's part, for he considered his actions to have been both zealous and faultless (Phil. 3:4-6). In short, there is no indication of any desire for conversion by either of these men. To suppose otherwise is groundless. In short, these men are exceptionally poor candidates for this disorder.
We just do not know enough about either Paul or James to say either way. Habermas wants us to assume they had no such disorder because there is no evidence they did, but the honest approach in that case is to admit we do not know either way.
That said, there is evidence Paul had this disorder, as the article above shows.
(3) Further, the psychological profile strongly opposes an application to any of these three apostles. Conversion disorder most frequently occurs to women (up to five times more often), adolescents and young adults, less-educated persons, those with low IQ's, low socioeconomic status, or combat personnel. [xxxi] Not a single characteristic applies to Peter, Paul, or James.
Habermas says it is unlikely for men like these three, which is a tacit admission that it does happen.
Less educated? Low socioeconomic status? That certainly applied to Peter and James. What is the deal with combat personnel? I would suggest witnessing Jesus crucified would be comparable to that.
(4-5) Further, holding that victims of conversion disorder are strong candidates for both visual and auditory hallucinations is stretching the case a bit. These are uncommon characteristics. [xxxii] Not only are these apostles poor candidates for the disorder in the first place, but even apart from this malady, they were additionally not predisposed to experience hallucinations.
How has Habermas determined that?!?
And here we even have two separate critiques, due to very different sets of circumstances. There is no indication that either James or Paul, in particular, longed to see Jesus. Their unbelief is a poor basis for producing hallucinations! James the skeptic and Paul the persecutor are exceptionally tough obstacles for the hallucination thesis! Once again, to say otherwise is mere conjecture apart from historical data.
For Paul, we have evidence of Gastaut-Geschwind syndrome.
For James... Well, the problem with James is we have no idea of the circumstances of his conversion. Or much about him at all - he is not even mentioned in John! Habermas seems to think that ignorance supports his case; I do not see how it can.
Again, all we can say is we do not know.
Habermas gives a number of other additional problems...
(1) Even individual hallucinations are questionable for any believers who felt despair at the unexpected death of Jesus just hours before. Their hopes and dreams had suddenly been dashed. Extreme grief, not exuberance, would be the normal response.
It was not hours before. Mark, the oldest gospel we have, is clear that the disciple first saw the risen Jesus in Galilee.
Mark 16:6 “Don’t be alarmed,” he said. “You are looking for Jesus the Nazarene, who was crucified. He has risen! He is not here. See the place where they laid him. 7 But go, tell his disciples and Peter, ‘He is going ahead of you into Galilee. There you will see him, just as he told you.’”
It would take the disciples several days to get to Galilee.
(2) The wide variety of times and places when Jesus appeared, along with the differing mindsets of the witnesses, is simply a huge obstacle. Men and women, hard-headed and soft-hearted alike, all believing that they saw Jesus, both indoors and outdoors, by itself provides an insurmountable barrier for hallucinations. The odds that each person would be in precisely the proper frame of mind to experience a hallucination, even individually, decrease exponentially.
Or all those Jerusalem appearances were made up decades later. Again, the earliest gospel tells us Jesus was seen in Galilee, days later.
(3) Generally, hallucinations do not transform lives. Studies have argued that even those who hallucinate often (or perhaps usually) disavow the experiences when others present have not seen the same thing. [xxxiv] Critics acknowledge that Jesus' disciples were transformed even to the point of being quite willing to die for their faith. No early text reports that any of them ever recanted. To believe that this quality of conviction came about through false sensory perceptions without anyone rejecting it later is highly problematic.
The key word there is "Generally". Habermas tacitly admits that it can happen when he qualifies it so.
(4) Of course, if the appearances were hallucinations, then Jesus' body should have been located safely and securely in its grave just outside the city of Jerusalem! That body would undoubtedly be a rather large disclaimer to the disciples' efforts to preach that Jesus was raised! But hallucinations do not even address this, so another naturalistic thesis is required.
The earliest belief was Jesus was resurrected in a new body. Read 1 Cor 15. Or read Josephus on what the Pharisees believed with regards resurrection.
14. But then as to the two other orders at first mentioned, the Pharisees are those who are esteemed most skillful in the exact explication of their laws, and introduce the first sect. These ascribe all to fate [or providence], and to God, and yet allow, that to act what is right, or the contrary, is principally in the power of men, although fate does co-operate in every action. They say that all souls are incorruptible, but that the souls of good men only are removed into other bodies, - but that the souls of bad men are subject to eternal punishment.
- Jewish War 2.8.14
To the first Christians, Jesus old body lay discarded like an old coat wherever he was buried.
The empty tomb and the bodily resurrection would invented later.
(5) Why did the hallucinations stop after 40 days? Why didn't they continue to spread to other believers, just as the others had?
There was a hallucination to Peter on his own, and then a group hallucination to all the disciples, both in Galilee. That was it.
(6) The resurrection was the disciples' central teaching, and we usually take extra care with what is closest to our hearts. This is what drove Paul to check out the nature of the gospel data with other key disciples on at least two occasions, to make sure he was preaching the truth (Gal. 1:18-19; 2:1-10). He found that they were also speaking of Jesus' appearances to them (1 Cor. 15:11).
It is telling that when the disciples were preaching, as Acts records, their arguments were based on texts from the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament). This is what they considered to be the most important evidence.
(7) What about the natural human tendency to touch? Would no one ever discover, even in a single instance, that their best friend, seemingly standing perhaps just a few feet away, was not really there?
Again, there were just two hallucinations, and the earliest Christians believed Jesus was risen in a new heavenly body. Would they expect to be able to touch it? Would they really try to touch the divine with their own profane hands?
(8) The resurrection of an individual contradicted general Jewish theology, which held to a corporate event at the end of time. So Jesus' resurrection did not fit normal Jewish expectations.
They believed this was the start of the end of time. Paul uses the phrase "first fruits" of Jesus to indicate he believed Jesus was the prototype of the coming general resurrection.
(9) Lastly, hallucinations of the extended sort required by this naturalistic theory are fairly rare phenomena, chiefly occurring in certain circumstances that militate against Jesus' disciples being the recipients.
Again, "fairly rare" is a tacit admission that it does happen.
What happened was certainly a very low probability event. But I would suggest a much higher probability that resurrection.
Comments
Post a Comment